Supplier Scoring: How to Evaluate Performance?

Article summary

  1. KPIs & PERFORMANCE
    • What are the key performance indicators?
  2. SUPPLIER SCORING
    • How do you evaluate your suppliers?
    • Continuous evaluation and performance monitoring
  3. TRANSPARENCY & COLLABORATION
    • Transparency in the service of supplier relations
    • Cooperation & Collaboration
  4. FAQ

KPIs & PERFORMANCE

What are the key performance indicators?

Measuring supplier performance relies on specific criteria that vary depending on your company's needs and objectives. However, there are key indicators commonly used to assess supplier performance, including:

  • OTIF (On Time In Full) : Respect for deadlines and conformity of products.
  • Product quality : Defect rate, compliance with standards and risk management.
  • Delivery time (Lead Time) : Punctuality and reliability of deliveries.
  • Costs : Adherence to budgets and identification of optimization opportunities.
  • Reliability of commitments : Rate of requests to modify confirmed orders.
  • Customer service : Effective communication, quick problem resolution.
  • Innovation : Proposal of improvements and creative solutions.
 

SUPPLIER SCORING

How do you evaluate your suppliers?

Several methods can be used to evaluate and rate supplier performance, including the following:

  • Quantitative evaluation: It is based on concrete numerical measures, such as the compliance rate, the on-time delivery rate, the defect rate, etc.
  • Qualitative assessment: This may include surveys of internal and external customers to gather opinions on the supplier's performance in terms of quality, communication, and service.
  • Performance dashboards: These provide a visual overview of supplier performance using charts and key indicators.
  • Rating: Assigning ratings or scores allows for a summary of the supplier's performance. 

 

Continuous evaluation and performance monitoring

Brands can define specific key performance indicators and receive alerts in case of deviations. This allows for continuous assessment of quality, on-time deliveries, and other critical aspects of the supplier relationship.

Management tools, such as supplier portals or control towers, offer customizable dashboards for monitoring key performance indicators (KPIs) throughout your supply chain. Based on operational data from your various suppliers, these tools support decision-making by enabling the implementation of priority actions when a change request is made. This allows for effective risk management and proactive planning.

Download our free guide on supplier management 

 

Here are some examples of indicators that can be monitored:

  • Percentage of orders delivered on time
  • Average delivery times
  • Average production times
  • Percentage of change requests
  • Discrepancies between quantities shipped and expected quantities
  • Percentage of compliant quality controls
  • Number of packages shipped
  • Delivery times
  • Rate of quantities rejected

These indicators not only improve performance but also enable a proactive approach to risk prevention and inventory reduction. By monitoring these elements, brands can quickly adjust their strategy and approach to maintain high service levels and ensure customer satisfaction.

Brands can support suppliers in their continuous improvement efforts and encourage them to evolve their practices to be more ethical and responsible. 

TRANSPARENCY & COLLABORATION

Transparency in the service of supplier relations

Transparent communication with your suppliers is the cornerstone of maintaining your relationships; here are a few reasons why:

  • Alignment of expectations: Communication helps ensure that your expectations and those of your suppliers are aligned, which avoids misunderstandings.
  • Strengthening relationships: Transparent communication strengthens trust and collaboration with your suppliers, thus fostering lasting partnerships.
  • Constructive feedback: Providing constructive feedback to your suppliers is essential to help them improve. It is important to highlight both their strengths and areas for improvement.
  • Problem solving: Open communication facilitates the rapid resolution of problems and challenges that may arise in the supply chain.

Cooperation & Collaboration

Thanks to a platform, an online control tower allows everyone to share information efficiently on a common repository, eliminating the need for email exchanges and the storage of attachments. This type of tool brings together stakeholders in the supply chain, providing them with a shared communication tool.

This network-based approach strengthens collaboration among employees, keeping them informed and enabling them to make effective decisions. A platform provides the tools for an ecosystem in which suppliers at various stages of manufacturing, carriers, quality testing laboratories, and different brand departments—production, quality, logistics, and marketing—interact.

 Online collaboration features between suppliers and brands enable efficient communication and collaboration, such as data exchange, validation or change requests, document sharing… Everything is centralized on a single platform, thus reducing delays associated with fragmented communications. 

FAQ

What are the main performance indicators for evaluating the quality and productivity of suppliers?

Key performance indicators (KPIs) to monitor: • Defect rate and product conformity. • On-time delivery and lead time. • Cost performance and budget optimization. • Inventory management and needs forecasting. • Responsiveness and quality of customer service.

How to establish and communicate clear expectations to suppliers?

• Clear definition of specifications and objectives. • Implementation of flexible and transparent contracts. • Use of key performance indicators for optimal monitoring. • Regular meetings and feedback sessions to adjust the collaboration.

What are the advantages of using software and digital tools for monitoring supplier performance?

• Real-time monitoring of KPIs and supplier performance. • Automated data analysis for better decision-making. • Data centralization for increased transparency. • Cost optimization and proactive risk management.

What quantitative and qualitative data are essential for a comprehensive evaluation of supplier performance?

• Quantitative: Defect rate, on-time delivery rate, cost savings, inventory levels. • Qualitative: Compliance with standards, responsiveness, satisfaction surveys, and supplier audits.